Hi,

I have a Soundsmith and I’m happy with it. It sounds like a modern cartridge, not dull like those of yore.

The re-tips I have are a disappointment. None sounds as good as my SMMC20EN.

So the SMMC20EN is a new cart they make and not a B&O re-build?

Right. The SMMC cartridges are a brand new cartridge, cantilever and stylus. 

The SMMC cartridges are completely different - they use more modern magnets and are essentially hand built. They are not as perfect in appearance as the originals but have a performance far more typical of the modern sound rather than the slightly laid back sound of the originals. The SMMC20 range are the same as the SMMC1-5 range but are encased in an external case. There are reviews available on site.

It's a matter of taste.

I am an older generation, preferring the warmer sound from the time when pleasant sound was more important than nice
looking numbers on specs sheets.
I don't listen to numbers. I find the modern sound sterile and wearing on the ears, occasionally to the point of feeling relief when I turn it off.

I would prefer a retip'ed original over an SMMC any day.

Martin

Thank you for your input. I appreciate reading about the difference in sounds it will help in my decision.

I am of the older generation as well as all of my equipment from my first turntable a Dual 1229 now running with a Shure M97xE, my Mac MR71 tuner on out to my B&O M70 and Sansui SP5500 speakers. All going through my newest piece a Accuphase E202 Integrated Amp I bought at the same time as my 4002 in 74. I'm also playing with my Crown SX824 and Teac 6010GSL to keep me busy.

I think I will go with a retip and keep everything of the same vintage (except the Shure) so now I need to decide on who to do it. Anyone use someone beside Sound Smith?

Thanks, Jim.

Hi Jim,

Where did you send the email?

Here is my email audio.origin.uk@gmail.com

And here is the page on the website about cartridge repairs