I'm not really an expert with these turntables (that's Martins title) but I'd agree with you that it sounds like the motor is faulty.
Any way, I've got your address and I'll post the motor I have to you next week. Not sure when you'll get it with it being Christmas and all that. I have studied the photo of yours and compared it to the one I have and I'm sure it will fit in the housing but you may need to swap the pullies over or do a bit of jiggling around to get it to line up with the one on the shaft. Hopefully though it will slot straight in.
Chris.