Sal wrote:
beojeff wrote:
I very much dislike the Tap. Hue's attempt at creating a remote that is powered by kinetic energy is quite a fail. A much more attractive wall remote (although quite costly) is the Moment wall remote. It can be programmed in LIGHT mode to work with the BLGW to control Hue. If you do get a BLGW, that opens up the world of Lutron RadioRa 2 wall buttons that can have backlit-engraving. It's very easy to set up and is as simple as installing a dimmer switch. It's easy to remove if you ever move. Even if you have a Hue lamp connected to that wall switch, you can make it work for you by hard-wiring the light load so that it is always on.
Thanks for the thoughts Jeff. I cede to your qualifications as the KING of B&O integration with the HUE Bulbs :-)
I'm still planning where my additions will go, and where the switches would make the most sense before purchasing, but knowing your thoughts on the Tap, can you explain why it is a fail? Is it the forceful press that's required, or is it a multitude of factors?
Let's start with the form. The Philips Hue Tap would fit in perfectly in Season 1 of "Space: 1999" with it's stark, clunky, white minimalism. NOT, however, in Season 2. That's because in Season 2 Maia would have transformed into a gorilla and thrown her first right into the bloody dimmer. It's a clunky, white disk that fits with Apple during the first generation of the iPod and the first generation of the iMac. Otherwise, it just doesn't look attractive in any decor.
Now let's talk about function. You really, REALLY have to give the Tap a firm, assertive press in order to get the button to be powered by the kinetic energy of the pressing action and send the signal to the Hue bridge. Mind you, this is not a casual "tap" (in irony to its name) that you might give upon entering or leaving a room. This just does not fit in with the lifestyle to which we're accustomed. It certainly does not feel like B&O. While Philips' innovation in creating a perfectly green remote that does not really on batteries or electricity, it just doesn't seem to serve a purpose unless we're recovering from a zombie apocalypse. In which case, we might benefit from the remote, but there would still be no electricity to power the lights. My gods, with today's technology, we should even have a touch-sensitive interface! The B&O Essence wall remote feels so much more natural to use. Plus, it has a wheel that can be programmed to adjust the intensity of the lights.