Ah! So much better - thank you :)

I really liked the new style, Lee. And everything was working for me, as on this layout I have frequent bugs...

You know, people who are not satisfied by something write more on forums than people that are satisfied... So for a small number of people complaining, there may have been a thousand people who had seen this update as a good thing... So maybe you listened to a minority by doing this... But you're the boss!

PS : why not a good old poll?

Ah thank you so much, so much better.

Well, I am all for change...

But... no question (and it is not familiarity) the navigation was is much better!

Hopefully Hawaii can eventually be duct taped together and we can move forward.

Thanks Keith!

Thanks Lee, you know it makes sense!

I do understand your predicament but the new layout was not good for established members to use, just think how prospective new members must feel in that environment.

Any idea what the use stats were while the new format was in use?

I am one for progress, but have to admit that I am glad we are back to the way it was. It seemed to take a few extra clicks just to get to the same places as before with less clicks.

I do realise that people like to moan, and if i don't see any validity in their moans i politely ignore them. However, in this case i did see their point - as did Keith and most members of the moderating team.

Personally, the Hawaii theme was very smooth and is definitely a step forward. The way it works is also very slick and bug-free, but that one single 'landing page' is something we just couldn't get our heads round.

I see the different forum section as a huge bungalow with 19 rooms in it - all with a different party happening.  The 'overview' let's you effectively 'lift the roof off' and look at every room from above - then you decide which party looks best to join.

With the new forum - you have to go into every room first.. time consuming and in my view a backward step.  So, a combination of the old and new is where we are best placed i think..

Page hits were well down when we changed - people weren't 'going for a wander' through the different topics so to speak.

Lee

Poor Lee!   
Doesn't matter which way you jump, folk are going to winge.
Personally, I don't like change, but realise that it is inevitable, so find it pointless wingeing.
Hoosomever, if it's a change I lkie, I'll be first to jump up and make my feelings known

9 LEE wrote:

I do realise that people like to moan, and if i don't see any validity in their moans i politely ignore them. However, in this case i did see their point - as did Keith and most members of the moderating team.

Personally, the Hawaii theme was very smooth and is definitely a step forward. The way it works is also very slick and bug-free, but that one single 'landing page' is something we just couldn't get our heads round.

I see the different forum section as a huge bungalow with 19 rooms in it - all with a different party happening.  The 'overview' let's you effectively 'lift the roof off' and look at every room from above - then you decide which party looks best to join.

With the new forum - you have to go into every room first.. time consuming and in my view a backward step.  So, a combination of the old and new is where we are best placed i think..

Page hits were well down when we changed - people weren't 'going for a wander' through the different topics so to speak.

Lee

 

 

I'm looking forward to this!