Alex wrote:
moxxey wrote:
Millemissen wrote:
even if you haven't got or can get hold of a PM MK1, there is still a possibility to play your FLAC-files on the MK2 (or the A9) - using AirPlay!
Most people with a PM (or a A9) nowadays have an iDevice.
I thought Airplay/Apple didn't support FLAC and neither does iTunes, so the primary way of supporting this was direct to NAS via DNLA? I'm confused :)
This is correct, actually. Airplay doesn't support FLAC.
Also the A9 never supported FLAC.
"Airplay doesn't support FLAC. Also the A9 never supported FLAC."
That is absolutely correct - but does not mean that you won't be able to play the FLAC-files you have on a NAS or on a Computer to a Playmaker MK2.
There are several iOS-apps, that support FLAC. These apps act as a 'renderer' as well as a 'controlpoint', and therefore are able to
play any file that the 'DLNA-server' serves them.
And - here comes the good news - these apps are nowadays able to use AirPlay.
This means that you within the app can choose any AirPlay device on your network as 'player' - Playmaker MK1/MK2, A9 and so on.
Any file that is send via AirPlay is send as ALAC in 16bit/44.1 Khz. Since FLAC and ALAC are both uncompressed formats, it works perfectly well.
All ripped CD's are 16bit/44.1 Khz - so no fuss there either.
Only problem is that, when you have FLAC-files in highres quality, they would the be downconverted.
But mostly owners of highres-files don't use AirPlay. In these cases I would recommend a PC or MAC with a 'powerfull software' and a very good DAC connected to the line-in of the Playmaker.
This is how I often do things. Actually it is easier to manage things this way - rather than playing via 'pure' DLNA. To play direct via the DLNA-function would need an extra step, and you would need to go into the settings of the app more often.
You could even have a 'Logitech Media Server' (formerly 'Squeezeserver') running on a NAS and - on the iPad - use 'Squeezeplay' or 'iPeng HD' with 'Playback' activated, and then AirPlay from within the app. This way you can even enjoy 'gapless playback', which isn't part of the DLNA-standart.
So still lots of possibilities to play high quality FLAC-files - even on a A9 or a Playmaker MK2.
If you start out new ripping your CD's - and don't mind using ITunes - you could even skip the DLNA-part totally, and use the 'Remote' app to AirPlay native ALAC-files.
Even local playback of FLAC-files on an iDevice is possible. When I have music on my iPad Mini for on the go, I use the 'FLAC Player'-app. And that one also has the AirPlay-function build in.
--------
Would be nice to hear from Moxxey and others how they consider(ed) using DLNA/FLAC with the Playmaker before learning that the MK2-version doesn't support FLAC via DLNA anymore.???
Greetings Millemissen