2 A1s vs 2 Balances?!?

32 replies

🙁

I realize this may not be possible in an office environment but is there any chance you can hardwire both speakers to the network.  Depending on how locked down the network is, this could inspire a nasty-gram from IT about connecting unauthorized devices to the network. 

Another troubleshooting question is whether the 2nd Emerge can run successfully on wifi as a standalone, and, if so, can you send music from one to the other (not in stereo)

Some office wifi networks are configured so devices can only talk to the internet, not to each other.  You would need special privileges assigned by the network admin to allow them to talk to each other if this were the case. 

Stan wrote:

I realize this may not be possible in an office environment but is there any chance you can hardwire both speakers to the network. Depending on how locked down the network is, this could inspire a nasty-gram from IT about connecting unauthorized devices to the network.

Another troubleshooting question is whether the 2nd Emerge can run successfully on wifi as a standalone, and, if so, can you send music from one to the other (not in stereo)

Some office wifi networks are configured so devices can only talk to the internet, not to each other. You would need special privileges assigned by the network admin to allow them to talk to each other if this were the case.

I definitely need to try running the 2nd Emerge as a stand-alone as you suggest.

I would like to hardwire both, but have been told by B and O that it is not possible to pair Emerges through a wired connection, only wirelessly, unfortunately. I really wish it were possible to hardwire them.

I had no idea that some WiFi networks are configured as you describe. However, I have tried the Emerges on both the work network, and on a hotspot network created by my iPad.
Reset the problem speaker this morning. Connecting to my iPad as a hotspot I was able to get all set up and working as it should and they sound great. It may be a problem with the network here as you described. I don’t really want to use my iPad daily as a hotspot. Although I do not really know why. I have never done much with a hotspot so not sure how that will work with the iPad coming and going?

I am still thinking about bring my BS5 to work and connecting the Emerges to it. For simple background music I can have it connected to the Ethernet and should not have any of the connectivity problems. If I want to listen to something that is not on the BS5, I could use either Bluetooth or my iPad hotspot?

I guess I will do some experimenting to see how things work with the iPad coming and going.

Hi Razlaw,

Glad you're making progress.  I'm surprised at how good the stereo A1s sound for this application - close by, low volume listening.  Then again, I don't think they will displace my BS2, but it's been an interesting exercise nonetheless.

FYI:  It's not unusual for corporate wifi networks (or any network managed by security minded people) to not allow inter-device access on the "open" wifi network.  This way, devices can come and go somewhat freely, but since the devices can only access the internet (which is what 99% of most random devices want to do), the security people don't have to worry too much about rogue devices breaking into network resources (including other devices on the network).  There's usually a "closed" wifi network that people access only on a "need to know" basis which has fuller capabilities, although some places will skip this in favor of wired connections (where, speaking from experience, excitable network admins may come running if you plug in an unknown device).

Stan

Stan wrote:

Hi Razlaw,

Glad you're making progress. I'm surprised at how good the stereo A1s sound for this application - close by, low volume listening. Then again, I don't think they will displace my BS2, but it's been an interesting exercise nonetheless.

FYI: It's not unusual for corporate wifi networks (or any network managed by security minded people) to not allow inter-device access on the "open" wifi network. This way, devices can come and go somewhat freely, but since the devices can only access the internet (which is what 99% of most random devices want to do), the security people don't have to worry too much about rogue devices breaking into network resources (including other devices on the network). There's usually a "closed" wifi network that people access only on a "need to know" basis which has fuller capabilities, although some places will skip this in favor of wired connections (where, speaking from experience, excitable network admins may come running if you plug in an unknown device).

Stan

Thanks! You know so much more about networks than I do. I have access to the both the closed WiFi network and the Ethernet connection. I am sure if I needed some setting changed it would be done for me, but I try to avoid troubling IT unless I have to. They have so much more important things to do than assist me with a B and O toy.
Finally have success and have the Emerges paired and working. I feel like I was really being stupid. I was setting up the Emerges on Wi-Fi but then connecting them to Ethernet. My mistake was thinking that once paired, only one needed to be connected by Ethernet. Now that I have both connected by Ethernet they are working great! Thanks so much for all of the advice!

Great to hear! So how do they sound as a pair? :) Can you describe them?

They sound great! Because of being at work I have not had them very loud. I will be trying that this weekend and will have more of an ability to give an opinion.

I am not sure if they can go too loud based on what I heard at my dealer’s but I also found them to be pleasant to listen to.

After spending some time listening to them at higher volumes, here are my thoughts. I am genuinely surprised at how good the stereo imaging is. Also, the volume is more than adequate for my needs. My office is approximately 250 square feet. At anything more than about 60%-70% volume they are much too loud to listen to comfortably. The sound quality is still great at those levels. For the price and size, I am as impressed with them as I am my 28s. But, I am weird as I much prefer my 28s to my former 50s. When I had the 50s I had no desire to replace my 1s, 6000s, 12-3s, 4000s, and 9s. The 28s have made me want to replace them with newer speakers and the Emerges have only strengthened that desire.

My 4000s definitely have a fuller sound than the Emerges, and I am not saying the Emerges equal 4000s. But to my ears, there is something about the Mozart products that I really like.
or
BeoWorld Gold Membership card
Join BeoWorld

Register to access the forums, reference material, and exclusive member benefits — including our monthly prize draw.

Become a Member

December 2026 Prize Draw

Gold Members Only

As a Gold member you're automatically entered into our exclusive prize draw — your chance to win iconic Bang & Olufsen products. A unique benefit of BeoWorld Gold membership, every draw brings a new opportunity to win something special.